friendsofjoey.com

Living Kidney Donation FAQ

Home
Kidneys: What do they do?
Dialysis
Living Kidney Donation FAQ
Success stories/Recipients in need
Latest Developments
Links
Bill's Bio/Contact Me

In this section, we'll discuss some frequently asked questions about how the living donation process works at the present time. I'll also talk about some myths and misinformation out there.

Q: "I am interested in living donation to a friend, loved one or a stranger who needs a kidney. Where do I go to find information?"

A: UNOS (United Organ Sharing Network) is an excellent scource for information on exactly what's involved in the process. I will be referencing this site often as it is the "go to" site for all aspects of living donation along with Transplantliving.org and OPTN (Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network). Currently, these organizations organize, facilitate procurement of organs and manage living donor databases. The initial testing and organ procurement process can be explained here:

The first steps to donating a kidney

Q: "How is the procedure done to remove the kidney from the donor and put it into the recipient?"

A: There are 2 types of surgery to remove the kidney from the donor. The first is Laparoscopic nephrectomy, also known as "keyhole surgery," is a minimally invasive surgical procedure for obtaining a kidney from a living donor that can make the process easier. In this procedure, the surgeon makes two or three small incisions close to the belly button. The kidney is removed through the central incision. Through one of the other openings, a special camera called a laparoscope is used to produce an inside view of the abdominal cavity. Surgeons use the laparoscope, which transmits a real-life picture of the internal organs to a video monitor, to guide them through the surgical procedure. In comparison to the standard operation, it results in a smaller incision, reduces recuperation time and usually shortens hospital stays. Many donors are discharged from the hospital after two days and return to normal activity within four weeks.

Not all donors can undergo laparoscopic nephrectomy. You may not qualify for the procedure if:

  • You have had multiple previous abdominal surgeries
  • You are significantly overweight
  • There is abnormal anatomy of the kidney


The second is Open nephrectomy and has been the standard for the last 35 years. It involves a five to seven inch incision on the side of the chest and upper abdomen. A surgical instrument called a retractor is usually needed to spread the ribs to gain access to the donor's kidney. Sometimes it's necessary to remove part of a rib for better exposure.

The operation typically lasts three hours, and the recovery in the hospital averages four to five days. Donors can usually return to normal activity within four to twelve weeks.

Q: "What's the risk for the donor?"

A: Kidney transplants are the most frequenty performed type of living donation. For the donor, there is little risk as the remaining kidney grows and compensates for the missing kidney. It is not uncommon for people to be born with one kidney and lead long, healthy and productive lives. The only way to tell if you have two kidneys is by ultrasound or MRI. Living donation does not change life expectancy, and does not appear to increase the risk of kidney failure. In general, most people with a single normal kidney have few or no problems; however, you should always talk to your transplant team about the risks involved in donation.

Q: "Who is eligible to donate?"

A: Generally, you must be first sure you want to go through with the procedure and are mentally prepared for it. Then, there are requirements that you be in good health, physically fit, no high blood pressure, diabetes, cancer, kidney disease and heart disease. Donors can range in age from 18-60 years old. Race and gender are not determining factors in good matches.

Q: "Can I sell my kidney?"

A: In 1984 Congress passed the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA), which prohibits the sale of human organs. However, the payment of "the expenses of travel, housing, and lost wages incurred by the donor of a human organ in connection with the donation of the organ" is expressly permitted by section 301 of NOTA.

View NOTA in PDF format

Q: "What is the cost of donation to the donor?"

A: Medical expenses associated with living donor evaluation are covered by either the recipient's insurance or in certain circumstances, by the Transplant Centers Organ Acquisition Fund (OAF). In either instance, the living donor should not incur any expenses for the evaluation. However, expenses related to another health concern that may identified during the evaluation process will not be covered by the recipient's insurace or the OAF.

The actual donation surgery expense is covered by the recipient's insurance. The transplant center will charge a recipient's insurance an "acquisition fee" when he or she receives a transplant. The medical costs related to the donation procedure and required postoperative care are also covered by this fee. In some instances, the actual itemized bill for the donor procedure is submitted to the recipient's insurance.

Anything that falls outside of the transplant center's donor evaluation is not covered. These costs could include annual physicals, travel, lodging, lost wages and other non-medical expenses. Although it is against the law to pay a living donor for the organ, these costs may be covered by the recipient. Be sure to check your specific insurance policy or ask a transplant financial coordinator about concerns related to your specific circumstances. You may also want to learn more about the National Living Donor Assistance Program which provides financial assistance to those who want to donate an organ.

Q: "What is the transplant list and how many people are on it?"

A: The transplant list is comprised of people who are currently waiting for kidneys in the United States. The number is constantly changing, but right now approximately 75,000 people are registered (most on dialysis) to get transplants as kidneys become available. Then, regional and state transplant centers conduct tests, match compatible donors and recipients and arrange the surgeries. Follow up care for both patients is provided by the centers.

Q: "I'm hesitant to sign my liscense to be an organ donor because I heard if you go into the emergency room and the doctors know your an organ donor, they won't work as hard to save you. Is this true?"

A: This a little off topic as we are discussing living donation on this site, but I feel this is a very prevalent myth out there. If you are sick or injured and admitted to the hospital, the number one priority is to save your life. Organ donation can only be considered after brain death has been declared by a physician. Many states have adopted legislation allowing individuals to legally designate their wish to be a donor should brain death occur, although in many states Organ Procurement Organizations also require consent from the donor's family.

Q: "My religion prohibits me from donating, so how is it possible to help?" 

A: All major organized religions approve of organ and tissue donation and consider it an act of charity.

Q: "What about the urban legend that involves drugging you and removing your kidney(s)? Has this actually ever happened?"

A: This tale has been widely circulated over the Internet. There is absolutely no evidence of such activity ever occurring in the U.S. While the tale may sound credible, it has no basis in the reality of organ transplantation. Many people who hear the myth probably dismiss it, but it is possible that some believe it and decide against organ donation out of needless fear.

Article from UNOS' website and is used for information purposes only.

Q: "What are the different types of living donation?"

A: There are three types of non-directed donation: 1) deceased-donor donation, 2) live donor/deceased-donor exchange protocol under an OPTN/UNOS allowed variance, and 3) living non-directed donation. With deceased-donor donation, the current OPTN/UNOS policy allows the next of kin the option to direct the donation to a specific individual or transplant center. There is generally no pre-existing relationship between the donor and the recipient and, while typically an anonymous process; anonymity may be waived if both the recipient and the donor family consent. With the live donor/deceased donor exchange protocol, the donation is conditioned on a "payback in-kind" to a specified individual. This approach falls under a specific allocation variance, which has been adopted according to OPTN/UNOS policy. In its final form, living non-directed donation is the only form of donation operationally designed to be truly altruistic and non-directed at the same time. Under a living non-directed donation model, the organ is donated as a gift and placed for distribution through the established allocation system. There are no expectations of return for the gift and no connections between the donor and recipient.

Q: "Are transplants from living donors always successful?"

A: Although transplantation is highly successful, and success rates continue to improve, problems may occur. Sometimes, the kidney is lost to rejection, surgical complications or the original disease that caused the recipient's kidney to fail. Talk to the transplant center staff about their success rates and the national success rates.

Q: "What are the advantages of living donation over a cadaver kidney?"

A: Transplants performed from living donors have several advantages compared to transplants performed from non-living donors (individuals who have been declared brain dead and their families have made the decision to donate their organs):

  1. Some living donor transplants are done between family members who are genetically similar. A better genetic match lessens the risk of rejection.
  2. A kidney from a living donor usually functions immediately, making it easier to monitor. Some non-living donor kidneys do not function immediately, and as a result, the patient may require dialysis until the kidney starts to function.
  3. Potential donors can be tested ahead of time to find the donor who is most compatible with the recipient. The transplant can take place at a time convenient for both the donor and recipient.

Q: "What is the recovery period and when can the donor return to normal activities?"

A: The length of stay in the hospital will vary depending on the individual donor's rate of recovery and the type of procedure performed (traditional vs laparoscopic kidney removal) although the usual stay is 4 to 6 days. Since the rate of recovery varies greatly among individuals, be sure to ask the transplant center for their estimate of your particular recovery time.

After leaving the hospital, the donor will typically feel tenderness, itching and some pain as the incision continues to heal. Generally, heavy lifting is not recommended for about six weeks following surgery. It is also recommended that donors avoid contact sports where the remaining kidney could be injured. It is important for the donor to speak with the transplant staff about the best ways to return as quickly as possible to being physically fit.

Q: "What if I donate and need a kidney later?"

A: This is something potential donors should discuss with the transplant team. Talk to your transplant team about any pre-existing condition or other factors that may put you at a higher risk of developing kidney disease, and consider this carefully before making a decision about donation.

There have been some cases in which living donors needed a kidney later- not necessarily due to the donation itself. It is considered a potential risk of donation. As of 1996, UNOS policy gives four extra points on the waiting list to living donors.

Q: "What are the total expenses involved in kidney transplantation?"

A: Compared with other transplants, it is relatively inexpensive to perform. According to Transplant living, the total cost as of July 1st 2005 is $226,000. This is for the transplant and first year follow up care. The real expenses are incurred when patients awaiting transplant are put on dialysis. Costs typically run around $500 per treatment, and it has to be done 3,4 sometimes 5 times a week for 3-4 hours. So, you can see why getting transplants to people on dialysis can be helpful to them and save the insurance comany money. It's a win/win.

Powered by Register.com